A comparability of government-backed contact tracing apps based mostly on 5 know-how rules
In response to a database maintained by MIT Expertise Overview, Aarogya Setu, India’s contact-tracing app to fight COVID-19, poses vital dangers to the privateness of the consumer in comparison with comparable apps in different international locations.
Although there’s little readability on the design and safety of the app, it has been made obligatory in some locations. The apps in China and Turkey pose better dangers for consumer privateness than Aarogya Setu.
Additionally learn: Coronavirus | What are the considerations across the Aarogya Setu app?
The next desk lists government-backed apps of 19 international locations based mostly on 5 know-how rules and whether or not the app adheres to them. ‘Y’ signifies compliance whereas ‘N’ signifies non-compliance. ‘NA’ signifies that there have been no information out there.
Voluntary: Whether or not the use is by selection or obligatory.
Restricted: Are there limitations on how the information get used?
Information destruction: Whether or not the information are deleted routinely after a sure period of time.
Minimised: Whether or not solely vital info is collected.
Clear: Whether or not the app is constructed on clear and publicly out there insurance policies and its design has an open supply code.
Viewing in app? Click on to view the desk.
A comparability of government-backed contact tracing apps
Desk seems incomplete? Click on to take away AMP mode.
Observations from the desk
India is among the many three international locations to make the app obligatory.
India is among the many 4 international locations to not have limitations on the usage of information.
Aarogya Setu’s code is just not open sourced thus hampering transparency.
Considerations surrounding the code have been highlighted within the public area lately.
Be aware: *The Ministry of House Affairs mentioned on Could 17 that each one employers “ought to on greatest effort foundation” be sure that the contact-tracing app is downloaded by all staff who’ve “appropriate cell phones”.